Boomer Money
  • About
  • Fine Print and Privacy
  • Glossary – Definition of Financial Terms

Don’t Outlive Your Money! Part 2 – Warnings About The Retirement Replacement Ratio

April 22, 2019 by Linda Vaughn

Retro black and white photo of man in suit and hat pointing his finger in warning to viewer not to rely on the retirement replacement ratio.

The takeaway: Boomer, beware the retirement replacement ratio.  Contrary to belief, it doesn’t help Boomers figure out how much money they need to retire.  The retirement replacement ratio may be fine for early- to mid-career workers, but not for Boomers who are on the brink of retirement.  This post explains why.  Have a look!

$$$

Part 2 in the Don’t Outlive Your Money Series.

$$$

Buenas tardes, y’all!  I came across a Market Watch article saying folks are more afraid of running out of money than they are of death.  

Not on my watch, Boomer.  This series is designed to make sure that doesn’t happen.  

So don’t get distracted by the flawed financial planning tool called the retirement replacement ratio.  I’m alerting you to it, so you don’t fall prey to thinking it applies to you.

If your pre-retirement spending is $100,000 and you plan to live on $70,000 in retirement, your retirement replacement ratio would be 70%.”

Vintage melancholy photo of man in hat wishing he hadn't used the retirement replacement ratio.

If only I hadn’t planned my retirement income needs around the retirement replacement ratio. It doesn’t work for Boomers on the brink of retirement.

What’s the retirement replacement ratio?

It’s the ratio of your post-retirement spending divided by your pre-retirement spending.  (Some people use the term income rather than spending when describing this ratio.)  

So, if your pre-retirement spending is $100,000 and you plan to live on $70,000 in retirement, your retirement replacement ratio would be 70% ($70,000/$100,000 = 70%).  

Boomer beware!  

Boomer, the retirement replacement ratio might be okay for your mid-career adult children, but not for you.  It’s no good.

The U.S. Government Accounability Office reported that the majority of financial planners they surveyed found that these replacement ratios only benefit early and mid-career workers. Such ratios give younger workers a goal for how much to save. When setting their retirement goals, these workers are commonly urged to aim for between 70% and 85%.

But if you’re in a low-wage job, you may need more than 85%.  Conversely, if you’ve got money coming out the, wazoo, defined here, you may need a lot less than 70%.

A ratio approach isn’t realistic for Boomers approaching retirement. 

The majority of planners surveyed in the  Government Accountability Office report indicated a better approach is to help folks:   

  • identify expenses,
  • determine which expenses will carry over into retirement, and
  • assess how much income will be required to cover these expenses. 

Translation:  track your expenses so you’ll know just how much income you’ll need in retirement.  (I just saved you a $250 consultation.)

What?!  You’ve done this already?

Cartoon drawing of word "Bravo" on gold background, applauding reader who used cation with the retirement replacement ratio..Bravo, Boomer! 

However, if like most mere mortals, you’re not exactly sure where all your money goes…

Help is on the way!

Boomer, Part 3 of the Don’t Outlive Your Money Series will help you identify where the money goes.  Knowing where it goes will help you identify how much will carry over into retirement.  From there you can figure out how much retirement income you’ll need.  

Then you’ll live (financially) happily ever after.  

Stay tuned.

$$$

Hi there! If this post helped you, could you consider sharing it on Facebook, LinkedIn, or Twitter? It's not easy being a small blog in a sea of a million blogs!! Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Linkedin
Posted in: Don't Outlive Your Money Series Tagged: Retirement replacement ratio
← Don’t Outlive Your Money! Part 1: Figuring Out How Long You’ll Need It
Continuing Care Retirement Communities, Part 1–Seven Essential Things to Know →

Recent Posts

  • On a Personal Note…
  • Self-Insuring Your Long-Term Care. (Almost) Everything You Wanted to Know but Were Afraid to Ask.
  • Resilience: Your Most Valuable Retirement Skill. Here’s How to Build It. (Book Review.)
  • To Not Outlive Your Money, You’ve Got to Know Where it Goes
  • How to Stop the Sting of Retirement’s Out-of-Pocket Medical Bills. (Or at Least Reduce the Pain.)
  • My Encounters in the Wild with Long-Term Care Sales Agents
  • The Three Factors Affecting Your Long-Term Care Insurance Costs
  • How to Evaluate a Long-Term Care Policy. (Hint! Know These Three Things.)
  • Staring Down Your Long-Term Care Odds—Much Better News Than You Thought.

Categories

  • Annuity series (6)
  • Basics: Money and Investing (15)
  • Book Reviews (13)
  • Boomers – The Fabs The Fails (9)
  • Don't Outlive Your Money Series (15)
  • Drawing Down Your Nest-Egg (3)
  • Long-Term Care Series (14)

Copyright © 2025 Boomer Money... and More.

Lifestyle WordPress Theme by themehit.com