Fixed Annuities: Higher Rates Than CDs. Worth it?

Black & white retro photo of two women, sitting at the bar, leering at a man's fixed annuity. Man off-camera.)

 

The takeaway: Fixed annuities are like CDs, except you earn a higher rate.  Even better, your interest grows tax deferred.  But there are steep penalties for early withdrawal.  And tax treatment isn’t particularly favorable to your heirs.  Look before you leap.

$$$

Part six in a series on annuities that will appear here from time to time.

$$$

When I was about 7, I was obsessed to find the money for a Toni doll. The Barbie doll hadn’t hit the scene yet. When I was with my mom and see a toy I wanted, she’d ask if I wanted that toy, or, did I want to put that money toward the Toni doll. 

Toni it was.

I still remember walking in the store with my jar of coins and buying that doll. 

Inexplicably, I have zero memory of ever playing with that doll. 

Buying a fixed annuity is a lot like buying a Toni.  You save up, buy it, and forget it.

Fixed annuities:  like buying a CD (or Toni).

Vintage black and white photo of stern mother talking to child, demanding a decision.

Which is it, Linda Vaughn?  The Toni or the ice cream cone?

Finding my Toni analogy lacking, the finance industry compares buying a fixed annuity to buying a certificate of deposit (CD). (They never knew Toni.)  You buy a fixed annuity by surrendering your money for a select number of years  Then you get it back with interest–just like when you buy a CD. 

However, unlike with CDs, fixed annuities generally pay higher interest rates.  At press, a five-year CD paid roughly 1% interest, while a fixed annuity with the same term paid about 3%.  You don’t pay taxes on the interest earned until you start collecting on the annuity—an advantage we’ll discuss shortly.

You can choose from two types of fixed annuity contracts.

Your choices are:

Retro black and white photo of a woman at a box office window ordering two fixed annuities: first a MYGA then one with a guaranteed rate.

Gimmie two fixed annuities.  First a MYGA.  Then, a single-year fixed with a high guaranteed minimum.  Got it?

  • a Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity contract (MYGA), which is bought with a lump sum and has a guaranteed interest rate for the life of the annuity;
  • a single-year fixed annuity contract, which can be bought with installment payments and has an interest rate that changes each year.
Retro black and white photo of a woman in an apron preparing food, claiming she'll sweeten the pie of a fixed annuity.

Hold on while I sweeten the pie for that fixed annuity!

Since you assume more risk with the latter, i.e., the single-year fixed annuity contract, annuity firms add some incentives to sweeten the pie.  These include:

  • a relatively high introductory interest rate,
  • a guaranteed rate at which your interest will fall no further, and
  • a bonus, which is a lump sum of money the firm adds to your annuity and is redeemed when the annuity matures.

Regardless of the type of contract you buy, how much interest you’re paid depends on:

  • how much money you put into the annuity and
  • how many years you hold the annuity.

Generally, the bigger the annuity and the longer you hold it, the more money you make.  Most fixed annuities are held from two to seven years.

Why might you buy a fixed annuity?

Retro black and white photo of a wealthy-looking woman in a boa and hat claiming she only buys fixed annuities to buttress her stock portfolio.

I only buy fixed annuities to add to my stock funds.

You might buy because:

  • you want a stable fixed-rate investment that will complement the high volatility and high returns of the stock funds you already own;
  • you’ve maxed out your traditional IRA, and 401(k), and want to continue deferring your taxes.

When a fixed annuity matures, you can roll it into a longevity annuity, deferring taxes even further, if tax deferral is your goal.

What are the advantages of buying a fixed annuity?

The four primary advantages are:

  • Interest accumulates tax deferred and pays a higher rate than competing investments, like CDs.
  • Compared to other annuities, fixed annuities pay low fees and low commissions.
  • Contributions are unlimited.
  • If you exit stage left, the annuity avoids probate.

Interest accumulates tax deferred and pays a higher rate than competing investments. 

Retro black and white photo of a woman in a skirt and pilot in a jump suit tring to get the propellers of a bi-plane started.

Yay! I have can travel now!  My fixed annuity is earning higher interest than a CD and the interest is tax deferred,

Since your interest accumulates tax deferred, you don’t pay any taxes on the interest earned until the annuity matures.  This allows your money to grow faster over time, than it would with, say, a CD.  This is because your annuity interest compounds uninterrupted by reductions from paying yearly taxes. 

Moreover, as noted earlier, fixed annuities generally pay higher rates than competing investments like CDs.  

Retro black and white photo of wealthy-looking woman trying on expensive hat, saying she can afford it, since she thinks she saved money when she bought a fixed annuity.

Don’t try to stop me!  With the money I’ve saved on fees and commissions, I can finally buy this hat.

Compared to other annuities, fixed annuities have low fees and commissions.

As shown here and here, fixed rate annuities have the lowest fees and pay sales agents relatively low commissions.  As a result, they’re not typically marketed with the exuberance of variable and equity-indexed annuities, which are lucrative to the annuity firm and sales agent, but not necessarily to you.

Contributions are unlimited. 

Retro black and white photo of three men using one match to light three cigars as they celebrate the taxes they deferred with their fixed annuity.

We’ve maxed out all our contributions, so we bought fixed annuities to further defer our taxes!  WooHoo!

Compared to employer sponsored retirement plans — whose limits are $64,500, and Individual Retirement Accounts, whose limits are $7,000 — you can deposit as much as you can afford in a fixed-annuity.  (The preceding limits are quoted for those over 50.)

If you exit stage left, the annuity avoids probate. 

Retro black and white photo of two illicit lovers about to kiss as one promises to bequest a fixed annuity to the other.

I can leave you my fixed annuity and no one will be the wiser. It isn’t subject to probate!

When you exit stage left, your annuity is not considered part of your estate.  As such, it’s not subject to your creditors or anyone else claiming access to it.  It simply goes directly to your beneficiaries. 

What are the disadvantages of a fixed annuity?

Retro black and white photo of woman with head in hand looking discouraged as she ponders all the pros and cons of a fixed annuity.

I’m really going to have to weigh the disadvantages of a fixed annuity. 

There four main disadvantages of fixed annuities. 

  • There are steep penalties for early withdrawal.
  • They provide no inflation protection.;
  • Upon inheritance, your heirs incur unfavorable tax treatment.
  • In rare instances, annuity firms have gone bankrupt (just ask me).

Steep penalties for early withdrawal. 

Although fixed annuities generally allow you to withdraw 10% of the value of your annuity each year without penalty, any additional withdrawals are subject to surrender charges.  Surrender charges typically start at 10%, then reduce by 1% each year, as shown below.

Figure 1. The fewer years you hold the annuity, the more money you lose, due to higher surrender penalties.

Source: Annuity Surrender Periods: Understand (and Avoid) Surrender Charges, The Balance, January 31, 2021.

No inflation protection. 

Vintage black and white photo of man holding lots of cash lamenting that he should have planned for inflation and never thought it would take all that cash to buy a loaf of bread.

Seriously, all this money for a loaf of bread? I shoulda planned for inflation! 

During the life of your annuity, interest rates on the on the open market may increase.  Unlucky for you, your annuity’s interest rate won’t change beyond what is in your contract.  Consequently, the annuity company will be paying new customers higher interest rates than they’re paying you.    

Even if the annuity firm offers to let you exchange the annuity for one with more favorable interest rates, via a 1035 exchange, you’ll still barely benefit.  Generally, you’re still subject to surrender charges with your current annuity. Plus, you’ll be liable for surrender charges on the second one as well. 

Unfavorable tax treatment to your heirs.  

Retro black and white photo of little girl with a giant bow in her hair crying because she may not get any inheritance on her parents fixed annuity.

I can’t believe they left me with this annuity tax burden.  Why didn’t they just buy mutual funds?

When your heirs inherit an annuity that’s appreciated in value, they’re obligated to pay income tax on the appreciated amount.  Hence, if you bought the annuity for $100,000, and at your exit it’s worth $150,000, heirs have to pay ordinary income tax on the $50,000 appreciation.  Ordinary income tax ranges from 10% to 37% percent, depending on your bracket.

Generally, your heirs would have ended up with  more money if you’d simply left them stocksbondsmutual funds, and real estate. If those assets had been purchased at $100,000, and appreciated another $50,000, your heirs could sell the assets upon receipt and owe no taxes. (!)  This is called a “step-up provision.”  You lovable overachievers can read all about it and watch the video here.   

Remember, always check with a tax professional skilled in annuity tax law.

In rare instances, annuity firms have gone bankrupt. 

Retro black and white photo of stunned woman hanging up an old fashioned phone after learning her fixed annuity has gone bankrupt.

OMG!  The annuity has gone bankrupt! 

Although it doesn’t happen often, annuity firms have gone bankrupt from time to time.  Read the post here.  And don’t let what happened to me happen to you!  You can seek redress from your state’s guaranty fund if the worst happens.  Residency requirements apply.

If the worst hasn’t happened and you want out before it does, read this post about getting about of a bad annuity.

Fixed-annuities:  a stable corner in your portfolio

If you don’t mind the risks associated with handing your money over to a company for two to seven years, fixed annuities can provide a portion of your portfolio that’s immune from the natural and expected fluctuations in the stock market.  With these annuities, you save up, buy it, and forget it. 

Just like with Toni. 

$$$

Extra extra!  Read all about it!

  • BluePrintIncome.com. Fixed Annuities:  A Safe, Guaranteed, and Tax-Deferred Way to Grow Your Retirement Savings,
  • BluePrintIncome.com.  Fixed Annuities:  A Safe Guide in Plain English.
  • Pechter, Kerry.  Annuities for Dummies, 2008.

$$$